THE BAT IN THE CAVE

 

Unexpected events make the hidden visible, often. But; does not make the unknown known. Because the unknown always manages to hide in another way. The reason for this success is largely the perception. The fact that the events are not 'expected' is due to the limited possibilities in the 'expectant' thoughts.

 This is one of the qualities of modern life: the limitation of possibilities in our heads. Technological facilities can improve people's abilities and expand their dreams. But the backplane doesn't change. There are roughnesses, indentations, and paths in the backplane. Their positions often do not change, and when they do, they do not move out of the surface. That is why, for all the colors and tones in the spectrum of the modern society, the previous state has been  defined, and the purpose aftermath  is to jump a tone at most, or perhaps a few colors beyond. Of course, the necessity to be within one band of the color of the spectrum is present in every age and society. Since there is a more intense pressure in societies that are said to be 'closed', the tonal bands are narrower. But; old, primitive, 'simple' communities accept the rupture of the spectrum faster and act according to the fact that what is happening is a change or a transformation. 'The anger of the gods', 'destiny', 'the punishment for the evil we have done' ... What happened has had been happenned, the one who came to the fate has had to be accepted. This had been  told in legends. For example, the Red Sea had been split [1], and the Noah's Flood  had covered the whole earth with water [2]. Whatever the explanations were, those have not been denied.

 It is not thought that there is such a possibility in closed or open, modern societies. However, we have centuries of knowledge that can explain natural and social phenomena beyond miraculous or great destruction. Yeah. But we are in a different system from primitive societies. This is such a difference that we do not know the other system, nature. Nature's own contradictions end very quickly enough to be said that there is no contradiction in nature. Because there exist also low probabilities. This quality of nature is at the root of the "miracles" and "destructions" of the primitive man. “Nature itself is not contradictory; however, it may be contradictory in terms of the particular human activity involved; characteristics of the environment take different meanings according to the historical and technical form of this or that type of activity" [3].The primitive man knew "non-contradictory" nature and was aware that his own activities constituted "contradiction".


Picture    Plato's Cave (1604) Jan Pietersz Saenredam and Cornelisz van Haerlem [4]


We live in a dream that we are in when we wake up. We cannot  use our scientific knowledge even to understand the range of colors we are trapped in our spectrum, let alone to recognize another system. Because; in the last few decades, we have moved away from the non-contradictory system over there, thoroughly, perhaps completely. We are fighting for survival on our spectrum. The colors of the spectrum also decreased and became very contradictory. There are no more tones, but dark and light colors. Poor and wealthy, East and West, immigrant and settled, male and female, child and adult, incompatible and compatible with the system, disabled and complete… Moreover, human and other living creatures outside the spectrum… Inequality society and exploited nature…

It must be harder to live in the subsets of a modern unequal society than in a primitive society. Because; no nature that helps, anymore. Beyond surviving, one has to be able not to die. No healing herbs, fresh air, water and soil. There is no agriculture. There is no forest. Most of the animals,  insects extincted [5]. There is science. But who cares?

 Therefore; sub-clusters of modern societies would not care also about a virus that suddenly appeared in an unnatural war, in a war where they are  on their own.

 While sub-clusters struggled to hold on to life, the supergroups sought a better "living". It was very unlikely that a virus would undergo a mutation, spread through mobility, and they did not know that low probabilities could occur, because they did not know nature. Then it was necessary to refuse. Perhaps, denial was the only view that all clusters agreed upon, since admission would make the  poor away from the work and result in  decrease of  the profits for the wealthy. Then the measures were denied. Mask were not seen as necessary for a while. Despite the scientists' declaration in July 2020 that the virus was suspended in the air, this  was ignored [6]. It started to be discussed much later that the indoor areas should be ventilated with appropriate methods and the number of people per unit area should be reduced. It is unclear what will happen next.

With the idea that he is almost alone on this earth, where it dries even the water beneath it, the human species sharpened the contradictions and reduced also its own diversity. It is now being asked to adhere to the meaningless measures introduced by the rulers of this contradictory system, many of which were taken in 'panic' to save the day. Even the educated people of this system defend that the virus is a conspiracy, oppose vaccination, have doubts because of the contradictions they see. It cannot be expected from the individual who has been violently suppressed when he  attempted to  be effective in ultimate condition, to obey the rules  which are due to  mostly delayed and meaningless measures. Before, everyone had to be well fed, treatment and education should be qualified, free of charge, equipped with infrastructures, especially ventilation, and working and retirement times had to be arranged in harmony with the physiological structure of the human being. That was the right thing.

Now, the individual who internalizes the inequality of the modern society tries to awaken from his dream with the fate of ignoring the nature, by saying 'all this is a game'. He is dreaming again. The supersets of the inequality are not able to find a way out, either. Where they come from is far beyond what their deterministic  understanding envisioned. While every living creature was a source of randomness, the glow that they thought  only the "hardworking, well-adapted" part of society could have had, had  began to fade [7]. Perhaps again, with these experiences, they will move to a wider spectrum with more colors. But this will not continue either. Because, they only see the shadows passing through the bottom of the cave. The truth is outside the cave. In nature, in equal society. It is in the visible world which is guarded by the sun [8]. Not in the virus spreading bat which is  in the cave we are hid.

1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/12/08/no-really-there-is-a-scientific-explanation-for-the-parting-of-the-red-sea-in-exodus/

[2] https://ncse.ngo/yes-noahs-flood-may-have-happened-not-over-whole-earth

[3] Levi-Strauss, Claude, Yaban Düşünce (In Turkish), Çev.:Tahsin Yücel, Yapı Kredi Yayınları, 9. Baskı, Şubat 2020., Sayfa: 132.

[4] https://www.nga.gov/collection/art-object-page.62542.html

[5] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-01448-4

[6] https://seyhanuyguronbasioglu.blogspot.com/p/newton-gelmedi-heisenbergi-bilmiyoruz.html

[7] Interview with Klaus Schwab (In German). Zeit Online, September 21, 2020.

[8] Platon, Devlet, (In Turkish). Çev.: Sabahattin Eyüboğlu,M. Ali Cimcoz, Türkiye İş Bankası Kültür Yayınları, XXII. Baskı, Ocak 2012,Sayfa: 233.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

KLARA AND THE SUN